If a man says he's a woman, then, in Scotland, he is a woman - except, apparently, for rapist Adam Graham, aka Isla Bryson.
Surely the broader problem here is the idea that ‘trans women are women’? That any man who says he is a woman is a woman? If you accept this idea, then you have to accept it for Bryson too, right? This is what I would like to ask Sturgeon: Do you think Bryson is a woman? Do you think his self-identification as female makes him female? If you do, why haven’t you put him in a women’s prison? And if you don’t, will you finally admit that JK Rowling and the many other critics of self-ID have a point when they say men are not women?
Just as well for her that her gender bill has been vetoed by the UK government. If it had become law, wouldn't Bryson have had a legal right to be held in a women's prison?
Posted by: AlanS | January 27, 2023 at 07:37 PM
Well...yes.
Posted by: Mick H | January 27, 2023 at 10:13 PM