Left Anti-Semitism

Mitchell Cohen in Dissent, on a left that learns and a left that doesn’t learn, and the question of anti-Semitism (via ALDaily). Worth reading in full, but here's his conclusion:

And so: If you judge a Jewish state by standards that you apply to no one else; if your neck veins bulge when you denounce Zionists but you’ve done no more than cluck “well, yes, very bad about Darfur”;

if there is nothing Hamas can do that you won’t blame ‘in the final analysis’ on Israelis;

if your sneer at the Zionists doesn’t sound a whole lot different from American neoconservative sneers at leftists;

then you should not be surprised if you are criticized, fiercely so, by people who are serious about a just peace between Israelis and Palestinians and who won’t let you get away with a self-exonerating formula—“I am anti-Zionist but not anti-Semitic”—to prevent scrutiny. If you are anti-Zionist and not anti-Semitic, then don’t use the categories, allusions, and smug hiss that are all too familiar to any student of prejudice.

It is time for the left that learns, that grows, that reflects, that has historical not rhetorical perspective, and that wants a future based on its own best values to say loudly to the left that never learns: You hijacked “left” in the last century, but you won’t get away with it again whatever guise you don.

Comments

[dearieme]

I suspect he's wrong though. I suspect that if the settlers in Israel had been Christian, or even Catholic, and had succeeded as well as Israel has, The Left would hate them too, and for much the same reason. It hates success. In particular, it loves to take sides against success in any contest where it can persuade itself that one side is basically White - and therefore must be held to high standards - and the other Black - and therefore excused any misbehaviour. Of course, its attitude is deep-dyed in racism, and its connection to biological reality in the Middle East is non-existent, but, hell, it's The Left.

[DaninVan]

Dearieme; "if the settlers in Israel had been Christian, or even Catholic..."
Left, Right, and ignored:
http://www.lebanese-forces.org/media/articles/malek/forgotten.htm

[SnoopyTheGoon]

I am afraid I have a bit of a problem with that last sentence:"...but you won’t get away with it again whatever guise you don."

Unfortunately they seem to be able to get away with it quite nicely so far.