« In the city | Main | Detroit from above »

July 12, 2017


Martin Adamson

As usual, there's no fool like a fully-engaged French intellectual. Setting up a genuine Kurdish state may or may not be the best solution, but it's dangerous to propose it without realising that it would take a long, prolonged war to do it. It's easy to criticise Sykes-Picot, but every other alternative solution would suffer from just the same defects.

Stephen K

'a long, prolonged war'

We seem to get them in the Middle East all the time anyway, so the argument from prudence looks a bit threadbare. If national self-determination and elementary gratitude mean anything (they don't to the established diplomatic actors, e.g. the State Department will do its best to stop this) the Kurds should have their independence.

The comments to this entry are closed.