An Instrument of Western Intellectual Hegemony

This sheds an interesting light on the difference between Al-Jazeera's English and Arabic outputs. Remember Ardipithecus Ramidus? A month ago?- Ardi for short:

The papers announcing the find described a transitional specimen, with the long arms and short legs of an ape and strong, grasping big toes suited to life in the trees, but also a pelvis whose shape allowed her to walk upright on the ground below.

That, at least, is what one discovered by following the coverage in the Western press, or by reading the scientific papers themselves, published in the journal Science. If you learned about Ardi on the Arabic-language version of Al Jazeera’s website, however, you discovered something else: The find disproved the theory of evolution.

“Ardi Refutes Darwin’s Theory,” Al Jazeera announced, in an Oct. 3 article not available on the English version of the website. “American scientists have presented evidence that Darwin’s theory of evolution was wrong,” the article opened. “The team announced yesterday that Ardi’s discovery proves that humans did not evolve from ancestors that resemble chimpanzees, which refutes the longstanding assumption that humans evolved from monkeys.”

Creationism, it seems, is on the rise in the Muslim world. Not in the sense that more and more people are denying evolution - outside of academic circles the question simply didn't arise - rather that more and more people are becoming aware of the threat to religion that evolution implies, and so more of an effort is being made to combat the Darwinian scourge. Witness. for example, Adnan Oktar, the bizarre figure behind The Atlas of Creation.

The phenomenon has raised concerns among scientists and educators - especially those in Muslim countries and in countries with growing Muslim minorities - who see in it a threat to scientific literacy, a drag on the potential for Muslim countries to build up their languishing scientific research sectors, and as another flashpoint in the Muslim world’s long-running struggle between religion and secularism. Unlike in the West, creationist beliefs are not associated in the Muslim world with religious fundamentalism, but instead are often espoused by members of the mainstream intellectual elite - liberals, by their own lights, who see the expansive, scientific-sounding claims of creationism as tracing a middle way between the guidance of religion and the promise of modern science. Critics of the movement fear that this makes it more likely that creationism will find its way into policies there, especially when the theory of evolution is portrayed among Muslim thinkers, as it often is, as an instrument of Western intellectual hegemony.

Comments

[Ran]

I'm not so sanguine about what's evolving from Islam, however...

Great blog Mick. [Tip o' the hat to Dan in Van.]

[DaninVan]

Ran's too modest
http://ifyouseekpeace.blogspot.com/

Ran and I are both relieved to know that we are indeed NOT descended from apes and pigs...:)